I have a blog that covers Permaculture, Paleo recipes, gardening, food preservation and whatever catches my fancy. http://www.ranchoseabowpermaculture.com
Graham Robertson wrote:Hi Paul, I was directed here form your email entitled "a paul wheaton community." The C Word always piques my interest, because of my trials within that realm and learning about all kinds of images and definitions that people build around it. I am 21 and quit school 6 years ago to pursue a life more connected to nature, myself and others. I have been part of a forming group of an off grid community and natural building business from the ground up as an apprentice with a man who says and dreams about a lot of the things I am hearing you say. I left that "community" because there was no concrete vision agreement, or established decision making process (at the least) before moving onto the land. We both had very different ideas about our values, visions, goals, interests, and most importantly what we share in common. This lack of understanding will slowly but surely erode group coherence.
I spent six months at Open Source Ecology's research center, Factor E Farm as a fabrication apprentice and learned what Marcin's idea of community looked like (basically the same as the former). Both of these places had the same traits in common, and more importantly the same results (very different visions though): development is at a virtual standstill, conflict either abounds or people got so fed up with power imbalances and shattered expectations that they left, or and both places have been completely deserted (at times), due to conflict. Neither have a committed forming group that shares a vision for the community. OSE has a very concrete vision, but do not be confused: OSE and Factor E Farm are two very different things. OSE is a global vision, FeF is one man's property where he plans to demonstrate the mission of OSE.
I have done a lot of research on what it takes to form a successful, resilient, working community, and it starts with a devoted forming group with a written understanding of the vision they share. Only 10% of ecovillages and intentional communities succeed, and that is what they have in common: a written vision statement BEFORE buying land TOGETHER.
I am writing this with the deepest concern and care in my heart, The one thing I have learned with the most conviction over the past six years of searching is the importance of revealing your deepest vision to others so that you can figure out where you want to take it. Alone or together?
You'll go fastest by yourself but farthest together.
I have talked to about a dozen people. Talked with voice. While standing next to them. Face-to-face. And they said "let me know the moment you have land, I will be there." They did not say "let me know the moment you are under contract and then give me details so that I can figure out if I want to be there."
I hear a lot of different expectations from you. On one hand you say you want to hold workshops and to start building stuff, and I understand that to mean dedicated visits from people,
but if you mean what you say in the title of your email: "paul wheaton COMMUNITY," I take that to mean a place where people share responsibility, legal, financial and decision making power. If we agree on that, then I suggest you read Creating a Life Together by Diana Leafe Christian. I believe it is the single most thorough and enlightening source on the topic.
there have been the dozens of people that have said that they want to come and be a part of what I do."
My advice is to find that devoted forming group and take time to decide WHAT your shared vision is and HOW to execute it, before even thinking about land buying. You will have your hands full if you invite people out onto your land that think they are joining a long term community. If you do not plan to share financial and legal responsibility, make it clear.
Maybe in a few years I could be paying people. And maybe this summer a bunch of people will move in and the idea of paying people will be silly. If nothing else it seems as if you are not familiar with WWOOFers or interns or organic volunteers.
There should be no maybes if you are in the land buying process and have remote expectations of people living and working on the land for any amount of time longer than a month.
If your intention is to invite people to volunteer, intern, or be farm hands for short periods, then agree to those roles and responsibilities in writing. But I also hear you saying that you envision people coming to stay for the long haul, which implies that you expect them to submit to your decision making process. How much responsibility are you planning to share with these people?
I've been planning this for a very long time. It sounds like my approach to this will be very different than your approach would be on the same land.
Do not call this a community if it is just you who has been planning the vision and direction, and only you who will hold legal and financial responsibility. You might do better to look at the centrally controlled spiritual communities and ashrams, as I am gathering that the ones who want to come out to stay are following you as a leader. What decision making process do you have in mind if you are inviting people to come out for extended stays?
kadence blevins wrote:
i dont have tons of tools or anything but i'm certianly good at stretching money wherever i can.
i dont have money to rent but i am more then willing to work on anything that needs done. and what i will be able to bring i certianly dont mind trading or sharing. heavens knows two people cant go through 2 gallons of milk per day and without fridgeration the milk/cheese/butter wont last too long anyways. and with the meat rabbits i should have plenty to bring live and butcher for eating as needed. and i'm currently working on getting some sheep which will be able to provide milk and meat and wool in time, meat probably being soonest depending on what becomes available to me.
kadence blevins wrote:
question...
lets say things go well and the land goes through. are you looking at people moving in, in june?
and double checking, that will leave enough time to put in gardens along with starting building? as that will help immensely with feeding everyone and taking produce to markets would help with incomes as well.
QuickBooks set up and Bookkeeping for Small Businesses and Farms - jocelyncampbell.com
Graham Robertson wrote:...but if you mean what you say in the title of your email: "paul wheaton COMMUNITY," I take that to mean a place where people share responsibility, legal, financial and decision making power. If we agree on that, then I suggest you read Creating a Life Together by Diana Leafe Christian. I believe it is the single most thorough and enlightening source on the topic.
QuickBooks set up and Bookkeeping for Small Businesses and Farms - jocelyncampbell.com
Jocelyn Campbell wrote:
kadence blevins wrote:
i dont have tons of tools or anything but i'm certianly good at stretching money wherever i can.
i dont have money to rent but i am more then willing to work on anything that needs done. and what i will be able to bring i certianly dont mind trading or sharing. heavens knows two people cant go through 2 gallons of milk per day and without fridgeration the milk/cheese/butter wont last too long anyways. and with the meat rabbits i should have plenty to bring live and butcher for eating as needed. and i'm currently working on getting some sheep which will be able to provide milk and meat and wool in time, meat probably being soonest depending on what becomes available to me.
This sounds incredibly resourceful, kadence. Though I think it would be hard to commit - either on your side, or receive a commitment from Paul's side - without the two-week (or more?) trial period.
Even if you've listened to all the podcasts, there are certain things that won't work themselves out until both you and Paul (etc.) are living on the land together. So, despite all the information we could convey via the forums, podcasts, phone, skype or e-mail, 'the proof is in the pudding,' so to speak.
Jocelyn Campbell wrote:
kadence blevins wrote:
question...
lets say things go well and the land goes through. are you looking at people moving in, in june?
and double checking, that will leave enough time to put in gardens along with starting building? as that will help immensely with feeding everyone and taking produce to markets would help with incomes as well.
Great questions. This depends on what happens with base camp (BC). The details are still being worked out on that, though currently, it likely means a later closing than May 31, which is the closing date for the land (TL).
Once BC closes, Paul will move in there first. (I'm still working out when I will move from the Seattle area to Montana. At this time, Paul does not have plans to move onto TL yet.) So, once Paul is set up at BC, people can join him for the two week trial periods. If BC closing is extremely rapid, or sped up somehow, I imagine mid-June might be plausible - though I really have no idea.
In addition, I think it will be even farther into the future before rental space, land lease space, or any other firm arrangements are completely clear and available.
Housing, poop management and earthworks are Paul's first priorities over setting up gardens or food systems. (Though hugelbed earthworks will likely be seeded and planted with food as a big part of some of the earthworks.)
Paul's first food production goal will be to feed the people on the land and those visiting the land for workshops, etc. Food for market might be a later goal of Paul's, or part of an individual community member's financial strategy - yes. Just not a main part of the first month activities in Paul's view (in my recollection - Paul can and will correct me where needed!).
Shenanigans of the sheep and wooly sort.. And many more.. https://www.instagram.com/girlwalkswithgoats/
Papa always says, "Don't go away angry... just go away."
If you want wealth, help others to grow wealthy.
Who said that?
Jocelyn Campbell wrote:
Graham Robertson wrote:...but if you mean what you say in the title of your email: "paul wheaton COMMUNITY," I take that to mean a place where people share responsibility, legal, financial and decision making power. If we agree on that, then I suggest you read Creating a Life Together by Diana Leafe Christian. I believe it is the single most thorough and enlightening source on the topic.
Hi Graham, it's heartening to me to hear of your path and how you're drawn to communities and learning so much in eco spheres. You're about the fifth person to suggest to Paul to read that book. Diana Leafe Christian is a friend of Paul's. In fact, on one of her recent visits to Seattle, we gave her my son's bedroom to sleep in.
Paul provided links to his community vision and more of his discussions on the community and decision making process in the thread the decision making process and conflict resolution.
I am thinking that this same framework that has served JavaRanch so well could be a foundation for an intentional community.
The JavaRanch dictator gets that role only because he got here first. Maybe that was lucky, or maybe it was unlucky. But he didn't get it because of being smart, or winning any beauty contest, or popularity contest, or race, or spelling bee, or .... anything that might be useful. He's the dictator due to a fluke.
You might wish that this fluke would have happened to you .... until you see what is required of the job and what kind of stuff this role gets saddled with. With this system, the dictator is the only person that says "no" to anybody (due to saying "yes" to others) - so you might be able to imagine how everybody else seems mighty nice, but there are lots of good folks spending a lot of time sharpening blades while thinking about that damn dictator.
The site belongs to me. The only real option is to leave.
kadence blevins wrote:
Jocelyn Campbell wrote:
kadence blevins wrote:
i dont have tons of tools or anything but i'm certianly good at stretching money wherever i can.
i dont have money to rent but i am more then willing to work on anything that needs done. and what i will be able to bring i certianly dont mind trading or sharing. <snip>
This sounds incredibly resourceful, kadence. Though I think it would be hard to commit - either on your side, or receive a commitment from Paul's side - without the two-week (or more?) trial period.
<snip>
i completely understand.
Jocelyn Campbell wrote:
kadence blevins wrote:
question...
lets say things go well and the land goes through. are you looking at people moving in, in june?
and double checking, that will leave enough time to put in gardens along with starting building? as that will help immensely with feeding everyone and taking produce to markets would help with incomes as well.
Great questions. This depends on what happens with base camp (BC). The details are still being worked out on that, though currently, it likely means a later closing than May 31, which is the closing date for the land (TL).
Once BC closes, Paul will move in there first. <snip> If BC closing is extremely rapid, or sped up somehow, I imagine mid-June might be plausible - though I really have no idea. <snip>
Housing, poop management and earthworks are Paul's first priorities over setting up gardens or food systems. (Though hugelbed earthworks will likely be seeded and planted with food as a big part of some of the earthworks.)
<snip>
of course. i think you said what i was thinking, just more clearly then i could think to say it ;)
QuickBooks set up and Bookkeeping for Small Businesses and Farms - jocelyncampbell.com
Marla Barak Sanders wrote:I would like to donate huckleberry seed/cuttings and would also like the option of a working vacation camp
option.
QuickBooks set up and Bookkeeping for Small Businesses and Farms - jocelyncampbell.com
A human being should be able to change a diaper, plan an invasion, butcher a hog, conn a ship, design a building, write a sonnet, balance accounts, build a wall, set a bone, comfort the dying, take orders, give orders, cooperate, act alone, solve equations, analyze a new problem, pitch manure, program a computer, cook a tasty meal, fight efficiently, die gallantly. Specialization is for insects.
-Robert A. Heinlein
lets say things go well and the land goes through. are you looking at people moving in, in june?
and double checking, that will leave enough time to put in gardens along with starting building? as that will help immensely with feeding everyone and taking produce to markets would help with incomes as well.
My books, movies, videos, podcasts, events ... the big collection of paul wheaton stuff!
Marla Barak Sanders wrote:I would like to donate huckleberry seed/cuttings and would also like the option of a working vacation camp
option.
My books, movies, videos, podcasts, events ... the big collection of paul wheaton stuff!
Chris Kott wrote:Graham, are you familiar with the concept of a feudal dictatorship? I think Paul's place might look a lot like that. His way or the highway, parameters set so that anything happening within those parameters meets with his approval, with final veto rights going to him. Full stop. No questions. Because those choosing to join him on his land have decided that his vision is superior to whatever else is available.
Paul, if I am wrong, please correct and enlighten.
-CK
My books, movies, videos, podcasts, events ... the big collection of paul wheaton stuff!
paul wheaton wrote:
I still have this idea that i would like to build a rocket mass heater in a teepee and have somebody live in it all winter and then make a video at the end of the winter asking them how comfy they were through the winter.
paul wheaton wrote:
lets say things go well and the land goes through. are you looking at people moving in, in june?
I would be okay with that.
and double checking, that will leave enough time to put in gardens along with starting building? as that will help immensely with feeding everyone and taking produce to markets would help with incomes as well.
It depends.
I suspect that the first people probably won't arrive until mid to late june. The current land is forest and meadows. Not something you can simply throw seeds on. So I think the earliest steps would be berms and hugelkultur. Then planting food crops.
paul wheaton wrote: If you make it through all of them and still want to come, then it will probably work out just dandy.
Shenanigans of the sheep and wooly sort.. And many more.. https://www.instagram.com/girlwalkswithgoats/
Papa always says, "Don't go away angry... just go away."
Emily Aaston wrote:
paul wheaton wrote:
I still have this idea that i would like to build a rocket mass heater in a teepee and have somebody live in it all winter and then make a video at the end of the winter asking them how comfy they were through the winter.
I would do that. What do you foresee happening on TL during a montana winter?
My books, movies, videos, podcasts, events ... the big collection of paul wheaton stuff!
My books, movies, videos, podcasts, events ... the big collection of paul wheaton stuff!
Kelly Kitchens wrote:I've got three weeks of vacation saved to invest in your trial period, but would like to time it when I can add the most value. I know y'all are swamped, but do you have any process yet for folks like myself to forward a resumé of skill sets, background, resources, etc. that we can bring to the table?
paul wheaton wrote:Kelly, I'm trying to route interview stuff to Jocelyn. <snip> But, the important part is, I think when we need help the most is at the very beginning.
QuickBooks set up and Bookkeeping for Small Businesses and Farms - jocelyncampbell.com
paul wheaton wrote:
Emily,
How many podcasts have you listened to?
Would you be a renter or a worker? What's your story?
I reckon it will get to zero. It's possible to get to 30 below. Lately the thermometer doesn't seem keen on dipping below zero.
If we agree on that, then I suggest you read Creating a Life Together by Diana Leafe Christian. I believe it is the single most thorough and enlightening source on the topic.
Ask me about food.
How Permies.com Works (lots of useful links)
My books, movies, videos, podcasts, events ... the big collection of paul wheaton stuff!
Random Stuff I do/like: 2matoes
Ryan Barrett wrote:I've been noodling on this one for a bit. <snip>
If the timing were to work out, I'd be able to do roughly 2 weeks.
<snip>
Overalls are cool.
QuickBooks set up and Bookkeeping for Small Businesses and Farms - jocelyncampbell.com
Marianne
check us out @ www.cricketscove.net
I have never met a stranger, I have met some strange ones.
Brenda Groth wrote:This is very exciting and I'm so happy for you and those that will join your evil empire. I had a thought that maybe I might be able to do some cuttingis of plants off of my property in the fall so that they might be ready for you the following spring, if my health holds out enough (recovering from pneumonia right now and lower back is in terrible pain)..can't do much but I might be able to do that. If I'm able to get you any cuttings that I could ship to you I'll let you know but you won't be ready for them until the trac work is done anyway.
Marla Barak Sanders wrote:I would like to donate huckleberry seed/cuttings and would also like the option of a working vacation camp
option.
Marianne Cooper wrote:Congratulations to everyone and their dedication to adventure. Jocelyn - if you have a donor of stuff list, please stick me on it - I have an organic orchard/berry farm/farm and nursery in VA. I'd be happy to send out black & raspberries, grapes (if they'd survive over & up there). could surely send over onion sets, garlic, hops etc. Early next spring makes the most sense, but surely your call.
M
QuickBooks set up and Bookkeeping for Small Businesses and Farms - jocelyncampbell.com
My books, movies, videos, podcasts, events ... the big collection of paul wheaton stuff!
A human being should be able to change a diaper, plan an invasion, butcher a hog, conn a ship, design a building, write a sonnet, balance accounts, build a wall, set a bone, comfort the dying, take orders, give orders, cooperate, act alone, solve equations, analyze a new problem, pitch manure, program a computer, cook a tasty meal, fight efficiently, die gallantly. Specialization is for insects.
-Robert A. Heinlein
A human being should be able to change a diaper, plan an invasion, butcher a hog, conn a ship, design a building, write a sonnet, balance accounts, build a wall, set a bone, comfort the dying, take orders, give orders, cooperate, act alone, solve equations, analyze a new problem, pitch manure, program a computer, cook a tasty meal, fight efficiently, die gallantly. Specialization is for insects.
-Robert A. Heinlein
paul wheaton wrote:It is possible that we will close early on TL. Possibly this week.
So my thoughts are turning to the stuff at the top of the list:
1: security. TL is a beautiful spot. The public has clearly been going there for years to bask in the beauty. Apparently, the previous owner put up a gate to keep the public out and the public ripped out the gate. We went to look at TL yesterday and there were some teens on four wheelers enjoying themselves (well, we saw one teen on a four wheeler). So there is one gate currently in place, and a need for two more. I think that the gates should be closed the moment a few people are prepared to be present on TL (near the gates) so that folks will get the idea "oh, I guess this really is private." Of course, for people to stay there, they need a pooper ...
2: pooper. I think the best thing to do is build a portable wheelie bin pooper. But if we build it up there and leave it there, then it could be vandalized or something. So it seems like construction on this might begin the moment that the gates close.
A sort of catch-22 thing.
Shenanigans of the sheep and wooly sort.. And many more.. https://www.instagram.com/girlwalkswithgoats/
Papa always says, "Don't go away angry... just go away."
He puts the "turd" in "saturday". Speaking of which, have you smelled this tiny ad?
Switching from electric heat to a rocket mass heater reduces your carbon footprint as much as parking 7 cars
http://woodheat.net
|