SKIP books, get 'em while they're hot!!! Skills to Inherit Property
Hans Albert Quistorff, LMT projects on permies Hans Massage Qberry Farm magnet therapy gmail hquistorff
Mike Phillipps wrote:I think this website was founded because the philosophy of buying a corporate petrochemical product for every need hasn't left the world or its residents with as good a quality of life as growing your own, at least some of the time. I think we're here in large part to share information on how to "grow your own". Are you sure you're at the right website?
Mike Phillipps wrote:
If you watch Paul's video from 1:00 to 5:00 , the guy says that it's trivial to take the bark off of a Black Locust pole.
Mike Phillipps wrote:
It's just as easy to cut 1-inch saplings as it is to drive several miles to a big box store, then have to pay for the items (if they have what you want. Access to "shelf materials" is not a given.), and haul those long poles back.
Mike Phillipps wrote:
PVC, petroleum, and dimensional lumber is more of a scarce resource and less-renewable than 1" saplings.
Anyway for these purposes, material like a 1" wood pole is substantially equivalent to a 1" plastic pipe. They are both polymer material. So a design that uses one is no more "from scratch" than the other.
Mike Phillipps wrote:A 10 foot stick of 1/2 inch wood is *totally* available, and probably closer to you, in greater quantity, with wider selection, provided more sustainably, with less toxicity and for a better price!
Mike Phillipps wrote:If going with the big-box store seems easier, it might be because you're relying on all the people running the store and the factories for their collaboration and for the specialization in the division of labor. If a local community, or "permies.com" had a similar level of collaboration and specialization in the division of labor, then this aspect would work just as well as a big-box store model, if not better.
Mike Phillipps wrote:Some designs might call for precision parts with tight tolerances but there are plenty of designs that don't require that, and having the flexibility to not need that is a good thing, because it allows one to use whatever is available. If you simply lash poles together for example, then you can use any size materials. In Asia they erect construction scaffolding out of bamboo and it is extremely strong. It is probably more economical, more sustainable and probably has a better strength-to-weight ratio than steel, making it more efficient, easier to put up or take down, and easier to move around when needed.
Mike Phillipps wrote:
Even if you use end-fittings, I don't recall you mentioning how you were going to fasten them. PVC cement isn't ideal. Using a set-screw is sort of convenient but rather weak. That method often fails. A clamping action is best because it grips the entire surface, is adjustable, reusable and is a custom fit every time. Wrapping with offers a similar method of clamping. It might not be ideal in every way, but it is effective, tried and true, and can be used with any fiberous/twine/string/rope material available, which is often rather economical. Again the sheathing material is conformally wrapped, so it does not require a precision structure. It is generally a lot easier, faster and more forgiving to build something when it doesn't have to be precise (because the allowable tolerance is greater).
Mike Phillipps wrote:This is like the argument between building log homes using natural logs, versus building them from kits made of machined dowels. If you really want everything to snap together like tinker-toys, you can probably put some sort of tool-die in a hand-drill chuck and quickly turn the end of a pole into a dowel. This isn't necessarily strong or efficient though. A clamping system is often preferred, even on tight-tolerance designs.
Mike Phillipps wrote:William, If you're going to go on a permaculture website and quote the "be nice" policy, can you please not post comments that attack the use of non-toxic alternatives to chorinated-plastic materials?
Mike Phillipps wrote:I already explained that wood poles are at least as available as plastic poles. It is easy to trim them.
Mike Phillipps wrote:Access to petroleum-based chorinated-plastics shouldn't be assumed to be "given", especially on "permies.com".
Plenty of people here don't live in the city. And plenty of people here consider wood poles to be more available than plastic poles. Plenty of people here are anti-plastic if there is an alternative, especially the more toxic chlorinated-plastics and ones with plasticisers that can potentially leach into the soil and food.
There's nothing wrong with folks suggesting alternative materials, especially when those materials are in many ways better.
Mike Phillipps wrote:A well known problem with a PVC hoop house is it doesn't hold up in wind and snow. Looking at the engineering data for "modulus of elasticity", that determines strength and rigidity, we see that most woods are 4 times stiffer than PVC, and even pine is 3 times stiffer. And this doesn't even include the fact that plastic pipe is hollow. http://www.engineeringtoolbox.com/young-modulus-d_417.html
Mike Phillipps wrote:Many of these woods are rot-resistant, including pine, and pine is extremely common, available and inexpensive.
If the wood is unpainted/untreated, then after several years the wood will rot, probably around the time that unpainted PVC would get sun-damaged, brittle and crack and flake off itty-bitty bits of chlorine plastic.
Mike Phillipps wrote:
If the greenhouse is covered, ventilated, and drained then it should be dry enough that wood and plants will be slow to rot.
You know, plants are also made out of wood, so the same environment that protects the plants from rot also protects a wood structure from rot. In other words, vent it enough to keep the humidity below 70% relative-humidity.
Mike Phillipps wrote:When plastic cracks and flakes in the sun, the only way to get rid of all those plastic bits is to shovel away all the dirt it's in. I've seen this first hand many times, even in material that you'd expect would be UV-stabilized like in an above-ground plastic swimming pool. Nope, there are now little bits of swimming pool everywhere all over the garden/lawn. It's very difficult to get rid of, and any chemicals in it will be leaching out for many years. You might as well know what you're signing up for. Just sayin'.
a little bird told me about this little ad:
permaculture and gardener gifts (stocking stuffers?)
https://permies.com/wiki/permaculture-gifts-stocking-stuffers
|