Looks like it's been 2 years since anyone's posted on this thread, so I'd like to re-ignite the discussion with my own
experience trying to raise a small flock of 5 chickens for the first time this spring and utterly failing.
First, you should know that I did a TON of research, including both Paul Wheaton's
books and
his excellent article here. After weighing the options, I decided to opt for the
Chickshaw Mini-Me + Paul's paddock system.
At first, this seemed to work like a dream. We even raised the chicks from day-old to teens inside a box inside the chickshaw, with a lamp hung over them. Since the chickshaw's lid pops up, this worked fine. We're in an older, inner-ring suburb of a larger
city on just 1/4-acre and have no garage or outbuilding and a cat inside we were afraid would mess with the chicks. One very adventurous chick did catapult herself out of the box, but a wire lid solved that problem.
Once they were out of the brooder box, they took to the chickshaw/paddock wonderfully. We used a 6-foot poultry net barrier around the chickshaw, keeping the chickens in an area where I wanted them to eat down the plants and till the soil for my future warm-season vegetable plot. But that one adventurous chicken kept getting out of the enclosure, even at 6 feet in height, though we never saw her actually fly over the netting. At 6 weeks, several of them would fly up to the top of the chickshaw, so it's possible. However, I think she was actually slipping UNDER the netting. We thought we solved this by folding the bottom under, secured by bricks.
When it came time to move the paddock, it went easy-peasy, as we only moved two of the fenceposts, basically rotating the paddock one square over. As you can see in the photo below, the warm-season veg is in the front in the former paddock, and the chickshaw is now moved behind it, where the chicks had a brand new paddock full of loads of fresh green plants to eat. We broadforked the area where the chickens had been, and they did their job admirably, as that bed is growing veg like gangbusters. It's awesome.
BUT, this is when tragedy struck. That one adventurous chicken was the first to go: She slipped out of the enclosure, again, underneath it despite the bricks. When we rotated it, there was a lot of vegetation in the new paddock spot, and the poultry netting gapped over some areas that we missed with the bricks. A hawk took her in the middle of the day out in the open, in a path between the garlic rows. I came home to find her still warm, her sisters gathered together in a pile right outside the opening in the poultry netting, as if in shock.
Not a week later, we had a really hard, overnight rain that saturated the ground. A predator (mink?) was able to push the poultry netting down enough to scale it, the posts bending over in the sodden ground. Then it slipped into the coop through the egg door in the back, which in
Justin Rhodes' Chickshaw Mini-Me design is open. It slaughtered the other 4. We'd only made it to 8 weeks with this flock of 5.
So now we have no chickens after all that work and expense. It's demoralizing, and my more conventional chicken-raising friends look at me like I'm a clueless noob who should have known better than to try something so "different."
I think the main problem here was that egg door on the back of the Chickshaw. As I mentioned in
this thread on the subject, the Chickshaw design is flawed; that egg opening is an invitation for predators to do what they did to our flock. So if we try this again, the first thing we do is close up the hole. Since the top "lid" lifts up anyway, it doesn't make sense to have a hole in the back.
I'm not sure what to do about the fencing. We had a flock of speckled Sussex, and maybe it's the breed, but I just shake my head at folks who say that chickens aren't going to roam. I'm with Paul and the others who don't want to dig into the ground to partially bury a more permanent
fence. I still think the paddock system works, and yeah, that one chicken was a problem, but it might have been OK for the rest of the flock. So maybe we try it again? I actually wish someone would make me a rollup fence that's weighted on one side so we don't have to weight it down with bricks over vegetation.
The other thing my conventional chicken-raising friends have pointed out is that the Chickshaw won't be enough of a shelter for overwintering the chickens. It's construction mesh on about 1/3rd of the sides. Do the chickens need more shelter from the elements in the winter? We're in Missouri, and last year was mild, but we can get below-zero temps F.
Curious to know what the community here can suggest. I was also very attached to these chickens--that durn roamer wanted to follow me around the garden, in fact--so I'm also still getting over the heart loss here. I think when you raise livestock you enter into a pact with the animals to provide for them so they will provide for you, and they held up their end of the bargain, but I failed them.
Besides covering the Chickshaw egg door, what changes should we make to our system?
Is the Chickshaw enough of a shelter in winter?
Any suggestions for how to keep the chickens inside the paddock?