I _think_ the poly-under-cob question is about moisture transmission up through the floor. If so, for anybody interested, here are some links concerning some techniques used to try to keep slab floors dry. The cob floor you're putting down is, I believe, the functional equivalent of a
concrete slab, so the technical points in keeping
water from coming up through the floor
should be similar. Unfortunately, there are no silver bullets.
Here is an excerpt from the first link where some engineers, architects and contractors discuss the question of a capillary break below a slab:
"
kslee1000 (Civil/Environmental)
2 Jan 09 19:38
For interior slab on grade, can anyone enlighten me when, why and how a "capillary break" becomes important factor on top of such typical concerns over strength of sub-base, and wet floor? We specify compact fill for strength concern, vapor barrier to prevent wet surface, drainage layer to divert seepage/uplift, what does "capillary break" serve?
msucog (Civil/Environmental)
3 Jan 09 09:13
it minimizes wicking of moisture up to the underside of the slab. even when there's a "vapor barrier", moisture can still transmit through to the slab. vapor barrier is a relative term unless you're really using something like a 30+ mil vapor barrier. the heavier the vapor barrier, the less moisture will transmit from one side to the other. the typical vapor barrier is very thin, easily torn and can transmit a fair amount of moisture. in other words, if moisture is present on one side of the "vapor barrier", some amount of that will likely be present on the slab side as well.
"
And the link:
https://www.eng-tips.com/viewthread.cfm?qid=234007
And here is a more technical article:
http://www.nrmca.org/aboutconcrete/cips/29p.pdf
The theory is that if the aggregate under the slab has large
enough cavities, pores, holes, whatever you want to call them, in it, then water will not be able to soak up through it. Common usage says that means 3/4 inch washed crushed stone, all one size. Ie. "uniformly graded" with no fines (small diameter material like clay, top soil). If the cavities between stones in the aggregate are not large enough, the aggregate will soak up water just like a sponge.
The general consensus in the discussion link above seems to be that the poly is what keeps the water vapor and liquid away from the bottom of the slab. However, a couple of contributors very specifically state that even poly only _retards_ moisture and liquid - it's not _water Proof_.
Regards,
Rufus