posted 2 hours ago
Permaculture is about using nature to do the work for us so we can get a harvest with less effort.
There are about 36 different methods to achieve any goal in a Permaculture garden. Not disturbing the soil is one of them, but not the only one. It's one tool in the tool kit.
Step one: look around your local wild areas. Ask, how is soil created naturally where you live? Most places, the leaves fall and decay on the surface of the soil with a mixture of fungus, bacteria, etc. Mulch.
Layering organic materials with mulch is a popular method in these locations.
It isn't that way so much where I live. Here, it's not warm enough at the same time it's moist enough, for mulch to really get working. The leavea have three main methods of becoming soil.
1. Via the gut of animals
2. Waiting until summer, and crumbling to dust in the drought
3. Disturbance where birds and animals dig the leaves under the soil where they can stay moist or warm enough to decompose.
So I use combination of all three and don't worry about disturbing the soil where annuals grow... the wild birds will do this to my garden with or without me.
If anyone says "never" or "always" chances are they don't understand permaculture or accidentilly mislabeled some other method.
Permaculture is all about looking at what is local to you, then using the tools that most closely matches the natural process...or better yet, encourages nature to do it for us.