Forums:

glass bottles/jars as roofing?

Posts: 278

Location: Iowa, border of regions 5 and 6

posted 8 years ago

Pam wrote:
You would have to watch it pretty carefully or in short order you might have nothing recognizable as "can"

Well, it might help in flattening it, anyway.

Posts: 33

posted 8 years ago

I think putting the can in the stove would damage the coatings, the organic matter will wash off with the first rain- the paper labels are only attached at one point, rip them off.

Len Ovens

pollinator

Posts: 1475

Location: Vancouver Island

posted 8 years ago

Heres one that some one has actually done... They have used vinyl LPs as a roof. If you have a rather large supply of them as this person did. The article I read (tree hugger if you want to look it up) says they were damaged... I would think in the manufacturing process. There must be lots of things that could be used for a roof.

Part of it is how long do you want it to last? We were on the beach, the wind was blowing and it was raining, we built a small hut from drift wood. For the roof we used seaweed (lots around in a storm) and even though the walls were full of hole (even in the windward side) it provided shelter. We could have slept there if we had too. We only did it for the fun of it and to teach our children (5 and 11) a bit about use of what they can see around them.

Here's a new topic.... finding something long lasting vs. quick and easy and rebuilding often. Are we too permanent minded?

Posts: 33

posted 8 years ago

vinyl will dry and crack when exposed to UV

Posts: 95

Location: Ferndale, MI- Zone 5b

posted 8 years ago

hillbillyarchitect wrote:
vinyl will dry and crack when exposed to UV

layer of thatch on top?

i have hundreds of lp's in my basement. it's a doable thing. plus, i've had records melt in my car with the windows up. they get gummy, and might almost be self-sealing!

i think it's a great idea and would guess that with good thatch coverage or a thin living layer on top, it might be good for many years.

charles c. johnson

Posts: 369

posted 8 years ago

here soon it will be dvd/ cd roofs

Posts: 278

Location: Iowa, border of regions 5 and 6

posted 8 years ago

charles johnson "carbonout" wrote:
here soon it will be dvd/ cd roofs

At one point I could have roofed my house with those AOL CDs they used to send out every other week. Seems to me if you're going to use CDs/DVDs you're going to have to:

a) decide if you're going to work shiny side up or design side up;
b) use some REALLY wide washers to fill the center hole;
c) use OSB for the roofing material (the one using LPs in the linked article just had thin strips of wood spaced wide enough for the LPs to be mounted.)

Come to think of it, if you used the shiny side up, you might pose a hazard to air traffic on sunny days. If you also kept the clear plastic CD containers, maybe you could glue them together in stacks and use them for windows, like glass blocks.

Christopher de Vidal

Posts: 100

posted 8 years ago

Given the difficulties of glass bottle roof as mentioned, would a green roof ala Mike's $50 Underground House be a better fit? Relatively inexpensive, good insulation, plus food production, and a whole lot less work than cutting thousands of bottles. Just wondering.

Christopher de Vidal

Posts: 100

posted 8 years ago

Heh, and then I found this link: $50 glass bottle cutter

Trudie Redding

Posts: 2

Location: Austin, TX

posted 8 years ago

but using this idea further, use the bottles and jars and create walls, natural light will come through but the bottles can help insulate, no need to cut, similar to glass blocks, but you must create the "bed" for them to lay in as they go up the wall, maybe others know of a mix that will work, plaster? A special mix created here in Texas from old phone books might work, it hardens like adobe, must be coated with something however , to make it waterproof, sounds like a fun project, make a small one as a sample and see how it goes,
T Redding
trrredding@gmail.com

Trudie Redding
Duplex Nation
Austin, TX

paul wheaton

master steward

Posts: 27486

Location: missoula, montana (zone 4)

∞

I like...

posted 3 years ago

I wonder if we could make a solar kiln, melt the glass (because we can no longer recycle here) and pour molten glass into tiles about 10 inches my 12 inches that have holes in the top to make them kinda like shingles .... and then make a clear roof of sorts. Not for the purpose of making a greenhouse or for a normal structure, but for walkways. And then plant hops at the foot of these structures.

Maybe we can have a rocket (wood fired) kiln also.

Come on out for my 2019 Permaculture Design Course and Appropriate Technology Course

gardening - sand badge (verified skill)
Skill verified by Nicole Alderman

dimensional lumber woodworking - sand badge (verified skill)
Skill verified by Nicole Alderman

natural building - sand badge (verified skill)
Skill verified by Nicole Alderman

round wood woodworking - straw badge (verified skill)
Skill verified by Nicole Alderman

r ranson

master steward

Posts: 14218

Location: Left Coast Canada

3111

I like...

posted 3 years ago

I think this is a marvelous idea!

Sort glass by type (something in my head says glass melts at different temperatures).
Use the sun to pre-heat the glass.
Rocket stove to melt the glass.
Some sort of mold to make the tiles.

My vision would be a yurt shaped, cob-walled dwelling, with kakishibu finished rafters. The kakishibu reacts with the sunlight to strengthen and preserve the wood. The glass tiles would be quite thick and slightly different colours and let in a diffused light. The downside would be in the summer as it would probably heat up the house a bit too much, but that's where the yurt idea comes in. Have the hole in the middle that opens, draw cool air from the open doors... might work. Might not. Perhaps a seasonal ceiling that is modular, easy to install/take down. So in the summer, it would have an attic where one can dry their harvest. In the winter, the ceiling is removed and we receive more light from the roof.

Homegrown Linen
crowing hen farm

How permies.com works!

r ranson

master steward

Posts: 14218

Location: Left Coast Canada

3111

I like...

posted 3 years ago

Here is a link to glass roof tiles

There seems to be a lot of posts in this thread saying it couldn't be done. None of the reasons given seem strong enough to me.

Too heavy - so is cement, tile, and living roofs. Too heavy, just build stronger.
Too much work - difficult to say this without first-hand experience. What's too much work for one person, may not be for another.
Weather concerns - this is important for any building material. How to address this would depend on the location. All roof is subject to weather.
Strength - This is an interesting one. Some glass is super-strong. Some is fragile. There must be a reason for this. I bet a glass blower would know why. This would be worth investigating. Talking with a glass expert might give some insight to the strongest shape and method for working with the glass.

If you have the resources already on hand, and the willingness to try. I say go for it.

Homegrown Linen
crowing hen farm

How permies.com works!

Dale Hodgins

pollinator

Posts: 8185

Location: Victoria British Columbia-Canada

617

posted 3 years ago

With any type of glass, it comes down to annealing temperatures. Each type of glass is very specific in both temperature and time it must be held at that temperature to avoid it blowing apart either immediately in the kiln or at some date in the not distant future. This is why very little recycled glass is used by blowers or other artists.

I have been to many so-called glass recycling places. I haven't seen anything that I would call the recycling. It's solid waste disposal. Sometimes it is broken up and put into gravel. This lowers the value of that gravel, and some unions refuse to work with this material.

If a uniform supply of bottles from the same manufacturer can be obtained, then there is a chance of successful annealing .

I have cut bottles in the standard fashion, but never tried to split them lengthwise. Should this prove too difficult, they could be slumped in a kiln. The slump mold could be curved and there could be clay nibs which would poke a hole as the material settles.

Tempered patio door glass is a much simpler product to use for a roof. It comes in uniform sizes.

When a clay tile in the center of a roof fails for some reason, replacing it is a very tedious process. Great care must be taken to avoid damaging the other tiles. Replacing a broken piece of glass would be a nightmare.

r ranson

master steward

Posts: 14218

Location: Left Coast Canada

3111

I like...

posted 3 years ago

Dale Hodgins wrote:With any type of glass, it comes down to annealing temperatures. Each type of glass is very specific in both temperature and time it must be held at that temperature to avoid it blowing apart either immediately in the kiln or at some date in the not distant future. This is why very little recycled glass is used by blowers or other artists.

That sounds like an important thing to learn about before going too far into the project.

I also noticed you said that very little recycled glass is used by blowers. That implies that some is used. Which suggests that the knowledge to do a project like this already exists in the world. This is inspiring news. All Paul needs now is someone with that skillset, or one willing (and able) to learn. It would be faster and safer than trying to learn from trial and error.

That slump mold sounds interesting, can you tell us more?

Homegrown Linen
crowing hen farm

How permies.com works!

Dale Hodgins

pollinator

Posts: 8185

Location: Victoria British Columbia-Canada

617

posted 3 years ago

Slumping is the least labor-intensive method of working glass that I'm familiar with. The item to be slumped is placed in the kiln and the glass is heated to the point where it will bend and settle into a form, but it does not completely melt. Many embossed art pieces are made in this way.

I met a blower who made use of scrap glass from a known source. This means they were able to determine the exact annealing method. Of all the art forms that I've witnessed, glass work is probably the most energy intensive. Vast amounts of natural gas are burned in order to produce a few art pieces each day.

Electric slumping kilns are much more energy efficient on a per unit basis. Pottery work is also far less energy-intensive on a per-unit basis. Many items can be stacked against one another during the bisque firing, whereas with glass, there must always be separation. Pottery must be cooled slowly, to prevent temperature shock but there is nothing comprable to the difficulties experienced when trying to anneal glass.

Glass is probably the most wasteful packaging product that people use. There are many drinks sold in glass bottles that are not refillable. Instead they put the recycling symbol on the side. From my knowledge of the subject, the chances of that glass ever being turned into another piece of glass, is well under 1%. If it is brought to a recycling facility, it will most likely be turned into a really poor version of gravel. None of the embodied energy in this product is salvageable. The resultant gravel chews up gloves and work boots and small shards can become airborne. Broken glass commonly contaminates paper, cardboard and other items that do really get recycled.

When compared to paper cartons that milk is commonly sold in, packaging a liquid in glass uses about 30 times more energy. The fake recycling symbol on the side is there too fool the purchaser into believing that they have bought an environmentally sound product.

David Livingston

pollinator

Posts: 4339

Location: Anjou ,France

240

posted 3 years ago

Couple of comments
Firstly have folks seen that you seen the documentry with the folks who enclosed their home in a huge green house , Scandanavia some where they certainly had a glass roof

Secondly I used to have a house with a stone roof terra-cotta is lightweight in comparison to sandstone

Thirdly here in europe glass recycling is big bizz yet I have no idea what they do with it but have never seen it used as gravel
Fourth I like the idea of making glass Lego
5th point here in France some glass containers are allso usable as drinking glasses so they have an extra life after .

Living in Anjou , France,
For the many not for the few
http://www.permies.com/t/80/31583/projects/Permie-Pennies-France#330873

Alex Everette

Posts: 4

posted 3 years ago

This is such an interesting thought........ I love it!

r ranson

master steward

Posts: 14218

Location: Left Coast Canada

3111

I like...

posted 3 years ago

As much as I love the idea of recycling the glass to be a roof (and I really hope someone does it, because I think it would be a smashing idea (well, maybe not 'smashing') - I'm putting it on my bucket list for a date in the future when I have the resources and time to play with the idea), ... as much as I love the idea, I'm rather surprised that you guys have so much glass. My limited understanding of what life is like at Paul's place, I would think glass bottles and jars would be a hot commodity.

I could see people being frustrated if the lids didn't seal properly, so they wouldn't be much good for canning or modern day food preservation, but there are loads of other ways to seal a jar or bottle for food (and other goods) storage. Bladders were very popular up to the early 20th Century, and beyond in some parts of the world. Wax is still used by some people today. Oilcloth, corks, wooden stoppers, cloth and string, &c. There are a lot of pre-industrial ways to seal a jar, so long as you aren't counting on pasteurization to sterilize the contents. Perhaps, if an Ant or Gapper was interested in food preservation, they could try a few of these things, show how they work, teach the others, then the problem will soon be a lack of glass jars and bottles.

If anyone's interested, I can put together a reading list and start a new thread on the topic.

Homegrown Linen
crowing hen farm

How permies.com works!

Glenn Herbert

gardener

Posts: 2917

Location: Upstate NY, zone 5

124

posted 3 years ago

Wide-mouth jars could be easily used for canning with one of the older methods like wax. Resurrecting that knowledge would be a good idea.

As far as roofing is concerned, glass bottles are designed to be strong as a whole unit; if cut into pieces like barrel tiles (the name for those half-round tiles) they would be much weaker, and I suspect practically useless for actual roofing. Champagne bottles might be an exception, but somehow I don't see those as a likely source for a whole roof's worth...

I think the slump molding idea is viable, though, as it would give double the thickness and no sharp edges. As bottles all have a narrow neck which is useless for rain-shedding coverage, I would suggest using them as tabs. Clay tiles in northern Europe, England especially, could be flat and used just like other shingles. It was probably most common to form them with one or two holes near the top, but they could also be given a lug at the top edge which would hook over a horizontal wood strip and stay by gravity. (The tiles with holes would slip over wooden pegs, not nails.)

You could shape a slump mold with a (say) 1" step at x" from the bottom, giving uniform exposed flat surfaces. The neck "tabs" would be hidden by the tiles above. Tiles need at least double coverage, so less than half the length of each tile is exposed, in order to shed water. This would make beer bottle tiles very small in exposure, while wine bottle-sized tiles would cover a lot more with the same labor.

To actually do this in quantity for a whole roof, I think you would need to develop a semi-continuous process, maybe refractory (heatproof) trays with the step formed in lengthwise, and a long kiln where trays could have bottles laid side by side and slowly be pushed in one end and out the other. Each tray would spend annealing time bathed in the exhaust from the kiln and slowly cooling until they emerged from the far end. Then the tray would be taken to the entrance end and be refilled with bottles.

Thekla McDaniels

gardener

Posts: 1909

Location: Grand Valley of Colorado's Western Slope

105

posted 3 years ago

Dale Hodgins wrote:
I have been to many so-called glass recycling places. I haven't seen anything that I would call the recycling. It's solid waste disposal. Sometimes it is broken up and put into gravel. This lowers the value of that gravel, and some unions refuse to work with this material.

Hi Dale,
I am disappointed to know this. I don't want it to be true, though suspect it probably is. I tried a web search and could not find anything to disprove what you say. There is some nice info from the glass container industry about 100% recyclability, and the cartoon of the bottles being sorted and melted, posters and such, but it looks like PR type stuff. I know what you say is true about the varying characteristics of various glass materials, and our recycling center limits the glass materials they collect to bottles and jars, because of the different melting properties, but now I wonder where the glass really goes. Can you refer me anywhere to give me more information about the "disinformation" about bottles becoming new bottles?

Thanks!

Best luck: satisfaction

Greatest curse, greed

Joshua Myrvaagnes

pollinator

Posts: 1133

Location: Massachusetts, 6b, urban, nearish coast, 39'x60' minus the house, mostly shady north side, + lead.

I like...

posted 3 years ago

didn't read the whole thing but my thought is less labor--just put all the bottles up whole, like the guy in the photo, it's not a complete roof but you are still putting another layer below. It serves function 1 of making the roof shinier to some degree, 2 of strengthening/buffering it more, 3 of preventing much from growing on top of the roof surface, if those are the goals. And it's added insulation in winter. Could do a double layer. Just wire the whole row of them in place. Saves on cutting, melting, etc.

Connected or reconnected. Fit with the right cycles and in the right season. Nourished and nurtured with natural energy. Aware of place and part.

Rebecca Norman

gardener

Posts: 1596

Location: Ladakh, Indian Himalayas at 10,500 feet, zone 5

228

I like...

posted 3 years ago

R Ranson wrote:I could see people being frustrated if the lids didn't seal properly, so they wouldn't be much good for canning or modern day food preservation, but there are loads of other ways to seal a jar or bottle for food (and other goods) storage.

Actually, you should just try your reuseable jars for canning, because they might well work fine. Jars in India mostly use standard sized lids; I think the same sizes are standard in Europe, but sadly not US. I find that reused lids work fine in canning the majority of the time, or we buy bulk lids every few years too. The reused jars are fine. Before canning season begins, we take all the used jars out of storage and wash them, and check in the sun for hairline cracks and scratches in the glass, and dents in the lids. Then we make our year's supply of apricot jam and juice, canning with hundreds of reused jars and a mix of reused and new lids. Very low failure rate.

Works at a residential alternative high school in the Himalayas SECMOL.org . "Back home" is Cape Cod, E Coast USA.

Dan Boone

gardener

Posts: 2378

Location: Central Oklahoma (zone 7a)

403

I like...

posted 3 years ago

When Paul wrote about "living in community" back in 2008, it was before (if I understand the timeline correctly) Wheaton Labs was a thing. Some of the recent responses talking about more practical uses for extra glass containers may have missed that. I'm betting Wheaton Labs has a smaller generation of surplus glass containers, although I do not know this to be so.

This thread has ranged far over the years from the original notion of mechanically reducing bottles to shapes useful as tiles. I find it hard to envision a process for doing that safely and routinely with reasonable amounts of labor and no industrial-scale machinery.

I like rather better the slumping kiln imagined in this thread, and I could also make great uses of sintered glass structural blocks. But the energy budget for any high-temp glass-recycling project is daunting.

I find myself wondering whether scaling down is better than scaling up. Is there any way to build a solar furnace that concentrates enough sunshine to "slump" a single beer bottle? Every morning at dawn on the way to the outhouse you take out yesterday's bottle-tile, put in today's bottle, check that physical security on your solar kiln remains adequate to exclude chickens and children, and get on with your life. That would be a permaculture approach, if it could be done.

Pecan Media: food forestry and forest garden ebooks
Now available: The Native Persimmon (centennial edition)

Lina Joana

Posts: 106

posted 3 years ago

I thought that organic meant derived from living things?

Rust is a chemical reaction involving oxidation/reduction.

That is correct: organic refers to molecules with multiple carbons - which in most cases, means originally coming from something alive. I think what was meant is that rust is naturally occuring while paint is synthesized - organic more in the "organic farming" sense of the word.
That being said, if you are planning on collecting water from a tin can roof, it might be worth asking what tin cans are treated with. If tin is treated with something to prevent rust, will that stuff cme off the roof over time, and is it healthy for you? I don't know, but research might be in order.

I'd love to hear whether anyone has worked more with the ideas in this thread. Any examples go up yet?

Davin Hoyt

pollinator

Posts: 253

Location: Central Texas (Georgetown)

151

I like...

posted 3 years ago

My first thought was to reform the material.

IMG_20160516_145321.jpg

Hire me!!! http://www.DavinHoyt.com
Got Rolly Shelves yet? https://permies.com/t/101765f35
BITCOINish freebie scenario: https://permies.com/t/101935

paul wheaton

master steward

Posts: 27486

Location: missoula, montana (zone 4)

∞

I like...

posted 3 years ago

Davin, that looks like a much better design than what I had. Although the shape would be tough for a mold. Is there a simpler shape?

Come on out for my 2019 Permaculture Design Course and Appropriate Technology Course

Davin Hoyt

pollinator

Posts: 253

Location: Central Texas (Georgetown)

151

I like...

posted 3 years ago

paul wheaton wrote:Davin, that looks like a much better design than what I had. Although the shape would be tough for a mold. Is there a simpler shape?

How is this?

section_glass.jpg

Hire me!!! http://www.DavinHoyt.com
Got Rolly Shelves yet? https://permies.com/t/101765f35
BITCOINish freebie scenario: https://permies.com/t/101935

paul wheaton

master steward

Posts: 27486

Location: missoula, montana (zone 4)

∞

I like...

posted 3 years ago

i guess i cannot get my head wrapped around that one.

Come on out for my 2019 Permaculture Design Course and Appropriate Technology Course

Davin Hoyt

pollinator

Posts: 253

Location: Central Texas (Georgetown)

151

I like...

posted 3 years ago

paul wheaton wrote:i guess i cannot get my head wrapped around that one.

glasstile01.jpg

glasstile02.jpg

Hire me!!! http://www.DavinHoyt.com
Got Rolly Shelves yet? https://permies.com/t/101765f35
BITCOINish freebie scenario: https://permies.com/t/101935

Jason Machin

Posts: 85

posted 2 years ago

Joe Skeletor wrote:Paul,

This guy made a video about the various ways to cut bottles. He has a method that works really great. Check it out - Joe

thanks Joe. I was worried I wouldn't be able to find that video. Use this method then cut the tubes in half.
Then set it up like a bamboo roof.

like the first part of this video...

paul wheaton

master steward

Posts: 27486

Location: missoula, montana (zone 4)

∞

I like...

posted 2 years ago

coupla things ....

44) what about when the tiles meet, left-to-right? It seems that water could get in there.

45) my experience with glass is very low, but I would guess that something square-ish would probably hold up better (kinda like glass panes).

46) should we have a way to be able to attach this stuff to wood? Maybe as part of the mold?

47) Are sharp edges (like the ones where the two glass tiles meet) easy to do with molds? Somehow I was thinking that the final product was more likely to be roundish

Below was my first thought. I could make a wood thing that would stamp this shape into the ground and then I could pour the liquid glass into it.

glass-tile.jpg

Come on out for my 2019 Permaculture Design Course and Appropriate Technology Course

Jason Machin

Posts: 85

posted 2 years ago

You could probably make shingles by flattening the glass. It'd probably use less heat. But they still wouldn't over lap on the sides.

I'd go with the bamboo method. It's designed to work with random pieces of bamboo rather then pressed and standardised clay tiles.
All you need is bottle halves and silicon cement (or whatever that stuff is called)

r ranson

master steward

Posts: 14218

Location: Left Coast Canada

3111

I like...

posted 2 years ago

Another example of commercially made glass roofing tiles

ew elegant glass roofing tiles have photovoltaics embedded right into the material, creating a completely seamless look with great curb appeal that is also an emissions-free source of renewable electricity to power nearly all of a home’s energy needs.

Homegrown Linen
crowing hen farm

How permies.com works!

Davin Hoyt

pollinator

Posts: 253

Location: Central Texas (Georgetown)

151

I like...

posted 1 year ago

paul wheaton wrote:Below was my first thought. I could make a wood thing that would stamp this shape into the ground and then I could pour the liquid glass into it.

In your mind, will light pass through the tile and enter an interior living or recreational space? Or will the tile rest on the roof sheathing (an opaque surface)?

Hire me!!! http://www.DavinHoyt.com
Got Rolly Shelves yet? https://permies.com/t/101765f35
BITCOINish freebie scenario: https://permies.com/t/101935

paul wheaton

master steward

Posts: 27486

Location: missoula, montana (zone 4)

∞

I like...

posted 1 year ago

Davin Hoyt wrote:

paul wheaton wrote:Below was my first thought. I could make a wood thing that would stamp this shape into the ground and then I could pour the liquid glass into it.

In your mind, will light pass through the tile and enter an interior living or recreational space? Or will the tile rest on the roof sheathing (an opaque surface)?

I am thinking that light will pass through.

Come on out for my 2019 Permaculture Design Course and Appropriate Technology Course

duane hennon

gardener

Posts: 836

Location: western pennsylvania zone 5/a

posted 1 year ago

this application makes use of the embedded energy already in the bottle
many variations of this

Well don't expect me to do the dishes! This ad has been cleaned for your convenience:

permaculture bootcamp - learn permaculture through a little hard work

https://permies.com/wiki/bootcamp

glass bottles/jars as roofing?

Similar Threads