Ask me about food.
How Permies.com Works (lots of useful links)
some of what I'm up to: http://www.permies.com/t/34620/projects/acre
Tom Rutledge wrote:It's summer! no one cares about heaters in summer... A pair of quick questions.
I'm working through a plan for a high mass super insulated RMH for storing process heat (say for example heating sugar water to drive off the water). How much pea gravel is in the bench and what are the exhaust gas temperatures on this stove at the start and end of a burn?
paul wheaton wrote:
There is something called Physics and we can't fight that.
Is there a point in this somewhere that I am suggesting that we fight physics?
If you pull air out of a room there is something is that is going to replace it . In HVAC terms this is called makeup air. (cool air?) You will either depressurize the room if it were totally airtight or air will find it's own way in. Nature abhors a vacuum. (Permaculture principle )
Which is entirely the point. I prefer to have the stale, stinky air removed from the room and replaced with fresh air from outside. Yes, the air from outside will be cold - and it is coming in while my rocket mass heater is running.
Check out my newest project at http://www.stadtfarm.com http://www.twitter.com/stadtfarms or https://www.facebook.com/StadtFarm/
Hans Albert Quistorff, LMT projects on permies Hans Massage Qberry Farm magnet therapy gmail hquistorff
Len Ovens wrote:
A few comments...
Comparing the temperature of a non-insulated mass and an insulated mass will not help. In the non-insulated case the temperature of the surrounding air, the walls, the objects outside the windows, etc. all effect how fast the mass is loosing heat. Adding insulation changes that... but there are already too many unknowns and adding insulation doesn't change that.
The needed temperature for the insulated mass determines the exhaust temperature or, looking at things differently, the amount of wasted heat. The advantage of the RMH is removing the greatest amount of heat possible before exhaust. Part of this is the barrel itself where a large amount of heat is radiated into the room, the heat to the storage mass is already cooled a large amount by then.
Len Ovens wrote:
So it seems that while the RMH is great for heating a room, it is not the best thing for making process heat. A well controlled Rocket Stove or a gasifier burner would make more sense for that application and probably use less fuel for the work. The exhaust heat could still be used for other purposes so it is not lost, such as preheating (if needed), home heating, providing domestic hot water or if all else fails heating the ground under the house for use when it is cold outside.
In the case you mentioned, evaporating water, the temperature required is relatively low, but the water itself soaks up a large amount of heat... that is it acts like a mass itself. The main thing is to keep from having hot spots that could over heat. I would suggest soapstone or cast iron for spreading the incoming heat. Well placed insulation could still be helpful... but probably more to keep the area cooler for people working there than saving heat. The evaporation process is generally a high heat loss deal... the surface of the liquid has to be open for it to work.
Tom Rutledge wrote:
I'm attempting to understand where the heat in a pebble bed RMH goes, and the approximate efficiency of transferring the heat between the exhaust pipe and the pebbles. I read somewhere on this forum that about 40% of the heat goes out the barrel and the rest goes out the bed / exhaust. I'm just gathering data points to understand the pebble bed version more. My hope was to burry most of the barrel in a pebble bed.
Tom Rutledge wrote:
just one quibbly semantic point, heat lost through the boiling process is the goal not a loss... but yes it's a loss to the system... quibble done.
Tom Rutledge wrote:
I am attempting to optimize somewhat for human time rather than strictly on fuel consumption. The load would be smaller batches of fluid a few times a day. It may be faster to have an already heated pan ready and waiting for service rather than having to start up a rocket stove and get it warm / burning clean and all that. There is also the further possibility that the process could be left unattended yet be fire safe, which would be totally awesome.
Support my videos by becoming a Patron
QR code for Bitcoin donations
www.oneheartfire.org to follow my personal permaculture adventures.
Now accepting Gappers for the Permaculture Bike Park project.
My Ant Love wish list:
Biodegradable Bar Oil for my chainsaw. I'm gonna need a lot of this for milling lumber with my chainsaw mill.
Darn Tough Socks that come with an unconditional lifetime warrantee! I go through socks like goats through a fence, these are supposed to last a lifetime or they send you a new pair! Size 12/XL please
Erik Weaver wrote:Very interesting. I would like to know more!
Questions:
1. The guillotine: I am curious about the construction details. Specifically, how is it made air-tight? Perhaps a rockwool gasket on the bottom, upon which the plate floats/rides?
2. The Bubble: Is that just an extension of the feed tube, with a closed lid on top? If so, is it a good idea to add an air port that may be opened (much like the air input ports on a traditional wood stove, used to control intake air flow) for 10 or 20 seconds before swinging the door open (to discourage a potential flare up of gases, suddenly exposed to a rush of fresh air)? And if so, how is the air intake flow managed (if the bubble encloses the feed tube opening, one cannot just keep the covering bricks snug against the wood)?
3. Gas venting. Some persons are interested in making code-buildable RMHs. I've read some code prohibits 100% closing the flue, and I have also read that some of the masonry heater designs take gas venting/escape into account, by placing 3/8" gaps allowing light gases to rise to the chimney. Has this been a subject of much discussion and/or trial?
God of procrastination https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q1EoT9sedqY
Check out my newest project at http://www.stadtfarm.com http://www.twitter.com/stadtfarms or https://www.facebook.com/StadtFarm/
Chad Sentman wrote:.
That said, could you explain in a different way what your mean with a rock-filled bell? I still don't follow.
God of procrastination https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q1EoT9sedqY
regards, Peter
God of procrastination https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q1EoT9sedqY
regards, Peter
Hans Albert Quistorff, LMT projects on permies Hans Massage Qberry Farm magnet therapy gmail hquistorff
Peter van den Berg wrote:Good question. I wouldn't call it stratification but convection instead. This is very much depending on the gaps between the rocks. So whether or not it will work as intended is unsure unless you could give a recipe of how large and how irregular the rocks should be. Doesn't sound like a transferable and repeatable experiment to me, more like a random shot in the dark. Sorry.
God of procrastination https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q1EoT9sedqY
Satamax Antone wrote:I've never said i wasn't shooting in the dark.
With the tiny bit of theoretical background i have, i get thoses ideas poping in my head. Often initiated by previous ideas from another field, or ideas from others And not having time to test thoses myself, i throw them in the air, to see if someone is keen, and would try it for himself.
regards, Peter
Life is too short or my list is too long, not sure which.
Peter van den Berg wrote:
Satamax Antone wrote:I've never said i wasn't shooting in the dark.
With the tiny bit of theoretical background i have, i get thoses ideas poping in my head. Often initiated by previous ideas from another field, or ideas from others And not having time to test thoses myself, i throw them in the air, to see if someone is keen, and would try it for himself.
<grin mode>So your assignment is to launch the idea and mine is to shoot at it.</grin mode> I would love to try some of these ideas but I don't have access to river rocks the size of a human head. I have to think it over, maybe I could cast those out of concrete. But I don't want to take on new experiments at the mo, since I have the MHA annual meeting in the pipeline.
God of procrastination https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q1EoT9sedqY
russell smith wrote:Regarding the pebble bed, have you experimented with different sizes of pebbles to see how well they breathe?
I have a sand pit near me that routinely has piles of larger rocks (egg sized) that get screened out& eventually dumped back into the pit for lack of demand, these are rounded stones as this part of the sate was under sea once, but i wondered if these were used in the mass bed, if some sort of screen was used under the bed, or slots were cut if air would circulate through the bed via convection.
Len Ovens wrote:
paul wheaton wrote:
So maybe just mount some sort of manual plug outside?
Maybe some pictures will help. All of these are from this page:
A story about an abandoned village. (Quite interesting in it's own right)
This first one is open but shows the inside quite well:
You can see the flue sticking up from the bottom. The chimney continues overhead. (brick)
The next one shows the cap and the outside door (not from the same heater though)
While all of this seems to be brick work, I see no reason this could not be done with cob or insulated tin.
Projects, plans, resources - now on the Permies.com digital marketplace.
Try the Everything Combo as a reference guide.
I need a new interior decorator. This tiny ad just painted every room in my house purple.
Learn Permaculture through a little hard work
https://wheaton-labs.com/bootcamp
|