posted 2 hours ago
I'll add that when you mix varieties in one patch they will fight for dominance. They are allelopathic, which means they spread chemicals that retard competitors, even other varieties. That means they will not grow to their best. That's also true when they're crowded without being mixed. I have a patch of two mixed varieties and discovered this the wrong way. In separate patches the varieties grow better, nothing stupendous, but clearly noticeable. I've also cut flowers from sections of patches for wine and there's no difference in yield between the deadheaded and the fully flowered plants.
I use a sod/garden fork to dig with. I've thought of making a shaker frame with 1' screen to help separate the tubers but just haven't gotten around to it. I've heard of small potato pickers modified for the smaller tubers that are pulled behind garden tractors. I don't grow enough to warrant that expense, plus the picker will only go so deep.
I wait for the tops to die and fully dry before harvest, that's when all the nutrients in the tops drain into the tubers making them their largest and full flavored. I got a small electric chipper and while I'm harvesting I chip the stalks and spread them over the patches, mixing in most of the chips as I dig. That's built up the soil very well. Yearly digging, yearly amending and mulching the tops loosens the soil very well. Yeah, sand will compress amazingly tight and hard, that's how sandstone is made.
Harvest as thoroughly as you want, it's very-very unlikely you'll take too many tubers as any tiny ones and roof nodules will sprout again.
I'm in west-central PA., zone 5. I harvest from when the stalks are dead until the ground freezes, then early in the spring I harvest more as soon as the ground thaws. Also, downwind of the Lakes I've got moderate to high humidity. That promotes powdery mildew which can be exaggerated by the plants growing too crowded, restricting air flow. Unless the powdery mildew gets too stout, it doesn't hurt the plants.
Keep digging, mulching and amending the soil and it'll loosen up.
Try Linux on your computer, free, no virus worries, stable and maintenance free. Distributions I recommend are Linux-Mint and Debian. Better than throwing your PC away when Windows rejects you.