OYSTER SOUP
Okay, so this recipe uses more store-bought ingredients than my typical meat-and-garden-veg soups, but an old oysterman friend of mine from the coast just brought me three quarts of fresh oysters, and this recipe is my dad’s and a favorite of mine growing up, so I decided to make it for us. It serves a bunch of people and contains approximately four trillion calories. I will give the recipe based on one quart of oysters since that’s what people usually buy. The batch I am showing here is three times the given recipe:
1 quart oysters, drained
1 medium onion, chopped
1 rib celery, chopped
½ cup green onion tops, chopped (only the green tops, not the bulbs or even the white parts of the stem, preferably)
¼ green bell pepper, chopped
½ stick butter
2 tablespoons oil
1 quart half-and-half
Seasoning to taste (I usually use salt, black pepper, red pepper, garlic powder, and/or Tony Chachere’s Green)
Here are pictures of the oysters draining and the rest of the ingredients ready to go:
The leftover green onion bulbs are in a cup with a little
water because the tops will regrow and can be trimmed several times before they are too sad to bother with anymore (or you can plant them).
This soup
should be made in a
cast iron pot. I always freshly season mine right before making the soup, because I don’t use the big pot that often and the onions must be cooked to absolute death, stirring often to keep from sticking, in order to satisfy my father (who believes that onions which still retain a hint of moisture or are paler than peanut butter impart a mysterious “tin taste” to the soup).
After you sauté the onions, you add the other vegetables and let them cook, stirring occasionally, till tender when smashed with a
spoon or tested between the teeth. They will barely cook more after this, so you want to get them done now.
Then you add the oysters and half the butter along with a preliminary round of seasoning on top (make sure not to overseason at this stage, since it’s not ready to taste), and give it a stir. Let them cook in their own juices until the edges begin to curl (or longer if you like your oysters more done), stirring every so often.
Now you add the half-and-half slowly in a thin stream, stirring constantly, and the other half of the butter. Stir occasionally while the butter melts and the half-and-half warms up. You do not want it to boil, or it will scorch. When it is a pleasant temperature for eating and you see little areas where tiny bubbles start to surface when you stop stirring (these will show up as pale spots on the surface), it’s ready.Turn off the fire so it doesn’t scorch. Season to taste and serve. You can add a little filé to your bowl right before you eat it, if you like, to enhance the flavor. It’s always better after a day or two to season, of
course.
If you need to reheat, do so carefully and preferably in small batches. We ruined a whole pot one time by putting it on the stove to heat and not paying close
enough attention, allowing it to scorch. Other ways we have ruined it include accidentally grabbing the cinnamon instead of the cayenne pepper and not tasting the half and half first, which turned out to be spoiled.
It can be served over white rice to make it go farther, like a gumbo, if desired.